Wednesday, May 2, 2012 Mermaid Inn

Mermaid Inn

568 Amsterdam Avenue

A glass of wine after a one hour dental appointment is always a good idea…..especially if it is at night.  Ed and I planned to meet after my dental appointment at The Mark Hotel on 77^th Street and Madison and head to the bar, but by the time we arrived, there were no empty seats and an obnoxious maître d’. It was 7:30, ,and  we were hungry so we decided to try The Mermaid Inn, a popular restaurant that is a block from our home and located  on Amsterdam and 87^th Street.   We had previously dismissed the idea of dining here because our experience at the bar was less than memorable.  Tonight, we were seated immediately in the back room which to that point we did not know existed.  The room had a country inn feel,  and although the seating was rather close,  the noise level was fine. 

It still is not clear why a restaurant chooses to serve wine in a glass that is more appropriate for a dinner at a bar mitzvah.  For those that are knowledgeable about wine, it does not give them the opportunity to swish and for those who just enjoy a glass of wine with their meal, part of the allure is a good pour that is served in an attractive glass.  The Mermaid Inn serves flatbread crackers with butter instead of bread which would be OK if the crackers were fresher and two guests were not allotted four crackers. The service and the timing of the meal was fine.  Mermaid caters to fish lovers, and except for the lone pork chops, the raw bar, appetizers and entrees are from the sea. There are several interesting choices, and Ed chose the grilled whole fish of the day which was a branzino which was well prepared with a crispy outside and tender fish. The entrée does not include a side which brings the price with an added vegetable to a steep $34.   At this price point, it is reasonable to expect well prepared food in a better than average venue.  My meal consisted of two appetizers of mussels and a chopped salad.  Perhaps it was my own lack of adventure that should be blamed for this less than exciting meal.  Yet, the mussels  in a boring red curry broth with smoked bacon and escarole with battling flavors made  this diner feel like the loser.  The main attribute of the salad was that it was big.

I am told that the Sunday lobster special for $24 is worth trying.  Perhaps…………………………